| Nina Dobrev and Claire Holt The Vampire Diaries Nina Dobrev, Claire Holt | Candice Accola, Paul Wesley and Nina Dobrev The Vampire Diaries Candice Accola, Paul Wesley, Nina Dobrev | Claire Holt and Paul Wesley The Vampire Diaries Claire Holt, Paul Wesley | Ian Somerhalder, Nina Dobrev and Paul Wesley The Vampire Diaries Ian Somerhalder, Nina Dobrev, Paul Wesley |
| Arielle Kebbel, Paul Wesley and Ian Somerhalder The Vampire Diaries Arielle Kebbel, Paul Wesley, Ian Somerhalder | Paul Wesley The Vampire Diaries Paul Wesley | Ian Somerhalder The Vampire Diaries (foreground) Ian Somerhalder | Arielle Kebbel and Ian Somerhalder The Vampire Diaries Arielle Kebbel, Ian Somerhalder |
| David Alpay and Paul Wesley The Vampire Diaries David Alpay, Paul Wesley | Paul Wesley, Michael Trevino and Candice Accola The Vampire Diaries Paul Wesley, Michael Trevino, Candice Accola | Michael Trevino and Phoebe Tonkin The Vampire Diaries Michael Trevino, Phoebe Tonkin | Nina Dobrev, Steven R. McQueen and Ian Somerhalder The Vampire Diaries Nina Dobrev, Steven R. McQueen, Ian Somerhalder |